Apollo Beach, Riverview, Ruskin, Wimauma, Sun City Center, Gibsonton & Lithia
If you live in Apollo Beach, Riverview, Ruskin, Wimauma, Sun City Center, Gibsonton, or Lithia, chances are your pool pump runs almost year-round. When a pump reaches 5–15 years old and starts leaking, getting loud, or failing to prime, many homeowners ask the same question:
Should I rebuild my old single-speed pump—or upgrade to a variable-speed pump?
At ASP – America’s Swimming Pool Company of South Shore, we help homeowners make this decision every week. Below is a clear breakdown to help you choose the option that actually makes the most financial sense.
Single-Speed vs. Variable-Speed Pool Pumps (What Most Homeowners Aren’t Told)
Single-Speed Pool Pumps
Operate at one speed only (full speed, 3,450 RPM)
Consume maximum electricity all day
Are typically louder and hotter
Often 5–15+ years old in South Shore communities
Cost significantly more to run monthly
Variable-Speed Pool Pumps (VSPs)
Adjust speed based on the pool’s needs
Run at lower RPMs most of the day
Use dramatically less electricity
Operate quieter and cooler
Include longer manufacturer warranties
Comply with modern energy standards
Why Variable-Speed Pumps Cost Less to Run (The Pump Affinity Laws – Simplified)
Pump energy usage doesn’t decrease gradually — it drops exponentially as speed is reduced.
50% speed = ~12% power usage
75% speed = ~42% power usage
Most pools in the South Shore area only need 1,500–2,200 RPM for daily circulation — far less than full speed. That’s why many homeowners save $400–$900 per year after upgrading.
When Repairing a Single-Speed Pump Makes Sense
A repair may be reasonable if:
The pump is under 5 years old
The housing shows no UV cracking
The issue is minor (seal or capacitor)
The repair cost is under $500
Typical repair cost in South Shore: $500–$800
When Replacing the Pump Is the Smarter Option
Most South Shore homeowners choose replacement when:
The pump is 5+ years old
The housing or lid shows sun damage
The motor has failed before
Repair costs exceed $500–$700
Electric bills are consistently high
Typical installed cost of a variable-speed pump: $1,800–$2,200
Real Cost Comparison
Repairing an Old Pump
Repair cost: $600–$1,000
Higher electric bills continue
Short or no warranty
Older technology remains
Upgrading to Variable-Speed
Installed cost: $1,800–$2,200
Saves $50–$90+ per month
Pays for itself in 1–2 years
Quieter, cleaner, more reliable
Why South Shore Pools Benefit Even More
Pools in Apollo Beach, Riverview, and Sun City Center often:
Run longer hours due to heat
Have screened enclosures restricting airflow
Experience higher electrical usage overall
Variable-speed pumps significantly reduce operating stress and energy demand in these conditions.
Schedule a Pool Pump Evaluation
ASP – America’s Swimming Pool Company proudly serves:
Apollo Beach • Riverview • Ruskin • Wimauma • Sun City Center • Gibsonton • Lithia
Call 813-322-5270
Email southshorefl@asppoolco.com